Victor and the Unintended Taste-Off
(As told in the Lantern & Ladle Tavern, usually after the second round)
Now, you have to understand something about Bramblewick: nobody meant for a competition to happen that day. Truly. It wasn’t planned, discussed, hinted at, or even suspected. It just… occurred, the way a roof begins to leak — naturally, inevitably, and with no one place or reason to assign responsibility. It was simply the natural unfolding of what had been, well... brewing for some time.
Victor had only just arrived, dust on his boots, traveling cloak folded over one arm. He did what he always did upon entering a new place: found a pleasant place to sit with a clear view of the area and let the world settle in around him. Victor was a respected figure throughout the gnome world, held in high regard for the depth of his experiences and the quiet weight of what he’d learned on the road. He’d barely sat down, pack resting on the cobblestones, when Figgy Wonderpudding came waddling across the square, holding a steaming mug as reverently as if it were a newborn calf.
“Thought you might want a proper welcome, as it were, sir,” Figgy said, in the tone of a man who is absolutely certain he’s offering the best tea in three counties.
Victor accepted the cup with a nod. He hadn't halway lifted the steaming cup to his mouth when the air changed — the way it does right before a storm or a very bad idea.
Because from the opposite direction came Spingle and Cringle, the swamp-side twins, walking in perfect unison and carrying a mug of their own. Their tea smelled of pepper, rain, and questionable decisions.
“Thought you might want a real welcome,” Cringle said, while Spingle shot an empirical, tight-lipped glance at Figgy.
The square went very quiet.
Not dramatically — just enough that everyone in earshot found a reason to stop what they were doing. A broom paused mid-sweep. A gnome at a nearby café froze mid-chew, slowly turning toward the scene. Curtains slid open. Faces pressed to windows. One might claim that even the pigeons held position overhead in mid-flight to see what would unfold.
Victor didn’t move at first. He held one cup in each hand — Figgy’s solid copper mug wrapped in hand-fired crockery, and the twins’ dense wooden cup, warm and heavy — and looked from one to the other with the calm of someone watching two waves roll toward the shoreline in steady determination.
He hadn’t come to judge anything. He had arrived, as he always did, by following the inner pull that was more him than anything that could be sensibly described. And in that moment, he was simply a gnome sitting on a bench, reorienting himself in a new place and taking in the scenery. But something in the air had gathered — bright, taut — a moment he sensed before anyone else recognized it. A disturbance, small and tangled, waiting to be eased.
So he lifted Figgy’s cup againand tasted it fully: bright, earthy, a touch of harnessed wildness at the edges. Then he tasted the twins’: deep, humming, the sort of tea you’d drink before doing something bold or slightly ill-advised.
The town held its breath. In the far distance, if you wished to embellish matters further, a forest bird may have called, or the wind may have rustled at just the right moment.
Victor lowered both cups, glanced around the growing crowd, and said — very gently, as if suggesting the simplest thing in the world:
“May I have a fresh pot?”
Now, Figgy looked ready to faint. The twins looked ready celebrate. The onlookers looked on with intensirt so as to be able to retell and reenact this moment in great detail for the next fifty years. But no one argued. No one even blinked. A fresh pot appeared as if summoned by the collective good will of the village.
Victor poured half of each tea into the empty kettle, swirled it once, and let it rest. He did not hurry — as was his practice. He simply waited for the blend to settle.
When he finally poured a cup, the liquid shone a deep amber that made several people gasp and one whisper, “Well… what do you know.”
Victor took a sip.
The silence deepened.
And then — a soft exhale, almost a quiet laugh, as if warmth spread through him in a way he’d been expecting all along.
“This,” he said, “is the one you’ve been brewing toward.”
He didn’t claim Figgy’s as the finer brew or the twins’ as the lesser. He didn’t settle anything, not even the question of whether a feud had truly been brewing in the first place. The village recognized the shape of the thing revealed before them — not a compromise, but a rising-together, a flavor neither tea could have found alone.
From then on, Bramblewick became known for its blended tea. Figgy continued brewing his bright forest leaf, and the twins kept perfecting their swamp-deep concoction — nothing about their craft changed. What did change was a new, mutual respect as well as a new morning ritual: a quiet ladle of one added to the other’s brew pot, not enough to claim a new recipe, but just enough to create the taste that had been discovered together. When asked about the blending, they would shrug and claim they added the ladle because they were “still experimenting,” or "still perfecting their craft" but the village knew better — their pride as brew masters remained, but so did their newfound respect for a rival's brew and methods. It had become their way of keeping that respect alive, as well as the peace Victor had rewoven into the scene.
And if you ever ask Victor how he brought two feuding teas into harmony, he’ll only smile in that quiet, knowing way of his — the smile of someone who insists he did nothing special at all. He simply listened to the moment; and in that small space where silence brushes against the faint echo of a dissonant chord, the notes begin to loosen, untangle, and weave themselves into a pattern that tastes, unmistakably, like the perfect cup of tea.

